Games like Witches Brew
Games like Witches Brew include Mirror, Chasing Tails ~A Promise in the Snow~, Summer Memories, NEKOPARA Vol. 1, and OshiRabu: Waifus Over Husbandos. We matched them by the tags players give Witches Brew on Steam (Supernatural, Sexual Content, Female Protagonist, LGBTQ+, and Dark Fantasy): closest matches first, and among equally close ones the better-known games.
Mirror
Shared: Sexual Content · Female Protagonist · Hentai
Chasing Tails ~A Promise in the Snow~
Shared: Sexual Content · LGBTQ+ · Hentai
Summer Memories
Shared: Sexual Content · Hentai · Nudity
NEKOPARA Vol. 1
Shared: Sexual Content · Hentai · Nudity
OshiRabu: Waifus Over Husbandos
Shared: Female Protagonist · Sexual Content · LGBTQ+
Steps of Debauchery
Shared: Sexual Content · Female Protagonist · Nudity
Futa Fix Dick Dine and Dash
Shared: Sexual Content · LGBTQ+ · Female Protagonist
Love Curse: Find Your Soulmate
Shared: Female Protagonist · LGBTQ+ · Visual Novel
Cloud Meadow
Shared: Sexual Content · LGBTQ+ · Nudity
Love Is All Around
Shared: Sexual Content · Visual Novel · Dating Sim
Volcano Princess
Shared: Female Protagonist · Choices Matter · Multiple Endings
Third Crisis
Shared: Sexual Content · Female Protagonist · Hentai
Third Crisis: Neon Nights
Shared: Sexual Content · Female Protagonist · LGBTQ+
Being a DIK - Season 1
Shared: Sexual Content · Nudity · Visual Novel
Summer Clover
Shared: Sexual Content · Hentai · Nudity
FEMBOY FUTA HOUSE
Shared: Sexual Content · LGBTQ+ · Hentai
Lucy Got Problems
Shared: Sexual Content · LGBTQ+ · Hentai
Love Ribbon
Shared: Sexual Content · Female Protagonist · LGBTQ+
NEKOPARA Vol. 0
Shared: Sexual Content · Nudity · Hentai
Magical Girl Witch Trials
Shared: Female Protagonist · Visual Novel · Sexual Content
Sweet Home
Shared: Female Protagonist · LGBTQ+ · Visual Novel
Road to Empress I
Shared: Female Protagonist · Choices Matter · Visual Novel
DRAMAtical Murder
Shared: Sexual Content · LGBTQ+ · Visual Novel
FreshWomen - Season 1
Shared: Sexual Content · Nudity · Visual Novel