Games like Whitetail Challenge
Games like Whitetail Challenge include Aimlabs, Drug Dealer Simulator, Dinosaur Hunt, Thief Simulator, and KovaaK's. We matched them by the tags players give Whitetail Challenge on Steam (Action, Adventure, Indie, Simulation, and Hunting): closest matches first, and among equally close ones the better-known games.

Aimlabs
Shared: Action · Simulation · First-Person

Drug Dealer Simulator
Shared: Action · Simulation · Indie

Dinosaur Hunt
Shared: Action · Indie · Adventure

Thief Simulator
Shared: Simulation · Adventure · First-Person

KovaaK's
Shared: Action · Simulation · Indie

Far Cry® Primal
Shared: Action · Adventure · Hunting

Far Cry 3
Shared: Action · Adventure · First-Person

Grand Theft Auto V Legacy
Shared: Action · Adventure · First-Person

Thief Simulator 2
Shared: Simulation · Action · Adventure

How to Fish
Shared: Indie · Adventure · First-Person

Bum Simulator
Shared: Adventure · Action · Simulation

Animallica
Shared: Adventure · Indie · Action

Internet Cafe Simulator
Shared: Indie · Simulation · Adventure

Far Cry® 4
Shared: Action · Adventure · First-Person

Wobbly Life
Shared: Adventure · Simulation · Action

Hand Simulator: Survival
Shared: Adventure · Simulation · Action

The Forest
Shared: Adventure · Action · First-Person

We Happy Few
Shared: Adventure · Action · Indie

Crime Scene Cleaner
Shared: Simulation · First-Person · Action

Deliver Us The Moon
Shared: Adventure · Action · Indie

Bendy and the Dark Revival
Shared: Action · Adventure · First-Person

Ale & Tale Tavern
Shared: Adventure · Simulation · Action

[Chillas Art] The Convenience Store
Shared: Indie · Adventure · Simulation

Slime Rancher
Shared: Adventure · First-Person · Simulation