Games like Toyeater
Games like Toyeater include Dagon: by H. P. Lovecraft, Mirror 2: Project X, Road 96: Mile 0, Road 96, and Slay the Princess — The Pristine Cut. We matched them by the tags players give Toyeater on Steam (Adventure, Visual Novel, Choose Your Own Adventure, Interactive Fiction, and Dark Fantasy): closest matches first, and among equally close ones the better-known games.
Dagon: by H. P. Lovecraft
Shared: Visual Novel · Horror · First-Person
Mirror 2: Project X
Shared: Visual Novel · 3D · Interactive Fiction
Road 96: Mile 0
Shared: Choose Your Own Adventure · Visual Novel · Interactive Fiction
Road 96
Shared: Adventure · Colorful · First-Person
Slay the Princess — The Pristine Cut
Shared: Visual Novel · Choose Your Own Adventure · Interactive Fiction
The Life and Suffering of Sir Brante
Shared: Interactive Fiction · Choose Your Own Adventure · Visual Novel
Roadwarden
Shared: Adventure · Interactive Fiction · Choose Your Own Adventure
Amanda the Adventurer 2
Shared: Adventure · Interactive Fiction · Choose Your Own Adventure
Milk inside a bag of milk inside a bag of milk
Shared: Visual Novel · Adventure · Interactive Fiction
Suzerain
Shared: Visual Novel · Choose Your Own Adventure · Interactive Fiction
Homicipher
Shared: Visual Novel · Choose Your Own Adventure · Horror
Amanda the Adventurer
Shared: Adventure · First-Person · Horror
PEAK
Shared: Adventure · 3D · First-Person
Firewatch
Shared: Adventure · First-Person · Atmospheric
DevilConnection
Shared: Choose Your Own Adventure · Interactive Fiction · Dark Fantasy
Class of '09: The Re-Up
Shared: Visual Novel · Dark Humor · Choose Your Own Adventure
Who's Lila?
Shared: Choose Your Own Adventure · Visual Novel · Interactive Fiction
Florence
Shared: Adventure · Visual Novel · Interactive Fiction
Tiny Bunny
Shared: Visual Novel · Horror · Adventure
The Hungry Lamb: Traveling in the Late Ming Dynasty
Shared: Visual Novel · Interactive Fiction · Adventure
The Wolf Among Us
Shared: Adventure · Choose Your Own Adventure · Visual Novel
Bramble: The Mountain King
Shared: Adventure · Dark Fantasy · Horror
Refind Self: The Personality Test Game
Shared: Visual Novel · Adventure · Interactive Fiction
Rewrite+
Shared: Visual Novel · Adventure · Interactive Fiction