Games like Toy Shire
Games like Toy Shire include Bloons TD 6, Starship Troopers: Terran Command, Broken Arrow, Men of War: Assault Squad 2, and Wargame: Red Dragon. We matched them by the tags players give Toy Shire on Steam (Tower Defense, Strategy, RTS, Cute, and Wholesome): closest matches first, and among equally close ones the better-known games.

Bloons TD 6
Shared: Tower Defense · Strategy · Family Friendly

Starship Troopers: Terran Command
Shared: Strategy · RTS · Military

Broken Arrow
Shared: Strategy · RTS · Real Time Tactics

Men of War: Assault Squad 2
Shared: Strategy · RTS · Action

Wargame: Red Dragon
Shared: Strategy · RTS · Military

Total War: THREE KINGDOMS
Shared: Strategy · RTS · Military

WARNO
Shared: RTS · Strategy · Real Time Tactics

Creeper World 4
Shared: Tower Defense · RTS · Strategy

Total War: WARHAMMER III
Shared: Strategy · RTS · Real Time Tactics

Total War: WARHAMMER II
Shared: Strategy · RTS · Action

Company of Heroes 2
Shared: Strategy · RTS · Military

Company of Heroes 3
Shared: Strategy · RTS · Wargame

Call to Arms
Shared: Strategy · RTS · Military

Call to Arms - Gates of Hell: Ostfront
Shared: Strategy · RTS · Real Time Tactics

Company of Heroes
Shared: Strategy · RTS · Action

Aliens: Dark Descent
Shared: Strategy · RTS · Action

Plants vs. Zombies GOTY Edition
Shared: Tower Defense · Strategy · Family Friendly

Master of Command
Shared: Strategy · RTS · Military

Steel Division: Normandy 44
Shared: Strategy · RTS · Military

Bad North: Jotunn Edition
Shared: Tower Defense · Real Time Tactics · RTS

Wargame: Airland Battle
Shared: Strategy · RTS · Military

Total War: NAPOLEON – Definitive Edition
Shared: Strategy · RTS · Military

Total War: EMPIRE – Definitive Edition
Shared: Strategy · RTS · Military

Steel Division 2
Shared: Strategy · RTS · Military