Games like Toby's Island
Games like Toby's Island include Wartales, Cassette Beasts, Stardew Valley, Persona 3 Reload, and DAVE THE DIVER. We matched them by the tags players give Toby's Island on Steam (Exploration, Creature Collector, Farming Sim, Party-Based RPG, and Turn-Based Strategy): closest matches first, and among equally close ones the better-known games.
Wartales
Shared: Turn-Based Strategy · RPG · Party-Based RPG
Cassette Beasts
Shared: Creature Collector · Party-Based RPG · Exploration
Stardew Valley
Shared: Farming Sim · RPG · Pixel Graphics
Persona 3 Reload
Shared: Party-Based RPG · RPG · Turn-Based Strategy
DAVE THE DIVER
Shared: Exploration · Farming Sim · RPG
Coromon
Shared: Exploration · Creature Collector · Turn-Based Combat
Clair Obscur: Expedition 33
Shared: Exploration · RPG · Story Rich
Aniimo
Shared: Creature Collector · Exploration · RPG
Monster Sanctuary
Shared: Creature Collector · Exploration · Turn-Based Combat
Chained Echoes
Shared: RPG · Exploration · 2D
For The King II
Shared: Party-Based RPG · Strategy · RPG
The World of Kungfu: Dragon and Eagle
Shared: RPG · Strategy · Exploration
FINAL FANTASY
Shared: Exploration · Party-Based RPG · RPG
Terraria
Shared: Exploration · 2D · Adventure
Yaoling: Mythical Journey
Shared: Creature Collector · Strategy · RPG
觅长生
Shared: RPG · Strategy · Open World
Solasta: Crown of the Magister
Shared: RPG · Story Rich · Party-Based RPG
Metaphor: ReFantazio
Shared: RPG · Turn-Based Strategy · Turn-Based Combat
Dokimon Quest
Shared: Exploration · Creature Collector · Turn-Based Strategy
OMORI
Shared: RPG · Story Rich · Indie
Digimon Story Cyber Sleuth: Complete Edition
Shared: Creature Collector · Turn-Based Strategy · RPG
Wandering Sword
Shared: RPG · Story Rich · Strategy
Ooblets
Shared: Creature Collector · Farming Sim · RPG
My Time at Portia
Shared: Farming Sim · RPG · Open World