Games like Toast Astronauts
Games like Toast Astronauts include Town of Salem, For The King, For The King II, Dota 2, and Bloons TD 6. We matched them by the tags players give Toast Astronauts on Steam (RPG, Strategy, Party-Based RPG, 2.5D, and 2D): closest matches first, and among equally close ones the better-known games.

Town of Salem
Shared: Strategy · RPG · Mystery

For The King
Shared: RPG · Strategy · Online Co-Op

For The King II
Shared: RPG · Strategy · Party-Based RPG

Dota 2
Shared: Strategy · Multiplayer · RPG

Bloons TD 6
Shared: Strategy · Multiplayer · Co-op

Wartales
Shared: RPG · Party-Based RPG · Strategy

Feign
Shared: RPG · Party-Based RPG · Multiplayer

The Escapists 2
Shared: Strategy · 2D · Multiplayer

Don't Starve Together
Shared: Co-op · Multiplayer · RPG

Divinity: Original Sin - Enhanced Edition
Shared: RPG · Party-Based RPG · Strategy

Dale & Dawson Stationery Supplies
Shared: RPG · Multiplayer · 1990's

Baldur's Gate 3
Shared: RPG · Strategy · Online Co-Op

OCTOPATH TRAVELER II
Shared: RPG · 2.5D · Party-Based RPG

Borderlands 3
Shared: RPG · Multiplayer · Online Co-Op

Mount & Blade II: Bannerlord
Shared: Strategy · RPG · Multiplayer

ShellShock Live
Shared: Strategy · 2D · Multiplayer

Pit People®
Shared: Strategy · 2D · Online Co-Op

Orcs Must Die! 2
Shared: Strategy · RPG · Co-op

Among Us
Shared: 2D · Multiplayer · Online Co-Op

Heroes of Might and Magic: Olden Era
Shared: RPG · Strategy · Multiplayer

PAYDAY 2
Shared: Co-op · Multiplayer · RPG

9 Kings
Shared: RPG · Strategy · Multiplayer

Castle Crashers®
Shared: 2D · Co-op · Online Co-Op

Terraria
Shared: 2D · Multiplayer · Co-op