Games like Time Warp Infinite
Games like Time Warp Infinite include Brawlhalla, Stick Fight: The Game, N++ (NPLUSPLUS), SpeedRunners, and Move or Die. We matched them by the tags players give Time Warp Infinite on Steam (4 Player Local, Quick-Time Events, 2D Platformer, Local Multiplayer, and Psychedelic): closest matches first, and among equally close ones the better-known games.

Brawlhalla
Shared: 2D Platformer · Local Multiplayer · 4 Player Local

Stick Fight: The Game
Shared: Local Multiplayer · 4 Player Local · Action

N++ (NPLUSPLUS)
Shared: 2D Platformer · Local Multiplayer · Precision Platformer

SpeedRunners
Shared: Local Multiplayer · 4 Player Local · Indie

Move or Die
Shared: Local Multiplayer · 4 Player Local · Action

Ultimate Chicken Horse
Shared: Local Multiplayer · 4 Player Local · PvP

Overcooked! 2
Shared: 4 Player Local · Local Multiplayer · Casual

Overcooked
Shared: 4 Player Local · Local Multiplayer · Indie

Duck Game
Shared: Local Multiplayer · 4 Player Local · Action

Rivals of Aether II
Shared: 4 Player Local · Local Multiplayer · 2D Platformer

Pummel Party
Shared: 4 Player Local · Local Multiplayer · Casual

Timberman VS
Shared: Local Multiplayer · 4 Player Local · Casual

TowerFall Ascension
Shared: Local Multiplayer · 4 Player Local · Indie

Gang Beasts
Shared: Local Multiplayer · Action · 4 Player Local

Lovers in a Dangerous Spacetime
Shared: 4 Player Local · Local Multiplayer · Action

Bloody Trapland
Shared: Local Multiplayer · 2D Platformer · Precision Platformer

Rivals of Aether
Shared: Local Multiplayer · 4 Player Local · Indie

Spelunky 2
Shared: 2D Platformer · 4 Player Local · Indie

Party Panic
Shared: 4 Player Local · Local Multiplayer · Casual

Sonic Superstars
Shared: 2D Platformer · Action · 4 Player Local

Twin Shot Deluxe
Shared: 2D Platformer · 4 Player Local · Action

A Few Quick Matches
Shared: 4 Player Local · Local Multiplayer · Indie

Crawl
Shared: 4 Player Local · Local Multiplayer · Indie

Timberman
Shared: Local Multiplayer · Casual · Indie