Games like Substitute Priest
Games like Substitute Priest include Sally Face - Episode One, Little Nightmares, Fran Bow, INSIDE, and The Room. We matched them by the tags players give Substitute Priest on Steam (Adventure, Point & Click, Interactive Fiction, Indie, and Atmospheric): closest matches first, and among equally close ones the better-known games.

Sally Face - Episode One
Shared: Indie · Adventure · Horror

Little Nightmares
Shared: Adventure · Atmospheric · Horror

Fran Bow
Shared: Point & Click · Adventure · Indie

INSIDE
Shared: Atmospheric · Indie · Adventure

The Room
Shared: Point & Click · Adventure · Atmospheric

The Room Two
Shared: Point & Click · Adventure · Atmospheric

Endacopia
Shared: Adventure · Point & Click · Horror

The Room Three
Shared: Adventure · Point & Click · Indie

Rusty Lake Paradise
Shared: Point & Click · Adventure · Indie

Detention
Shared: Indie · Adventure · Atmospheric

Little Misfortune
Shared: Point & Click · Indie · Adventure

Little Nightmares II
Shared: Adventure · Horror · Atmospheric

The Excavation of Hob's Barrow
Shared: Adventure · Point & Click · Horror

Chants of Sennaar
Shared: Adventure · Indie · Point & Click

The Cat Lady
Shared: Adventure · Indie · Point & Click

LIMBO
Shared: Indie · Adventure · Atmospheric

Servant of the Lake
Shared: Adventure · Point & Click · Indie

Samsara Room
Shared: Adventure · Indie · Point & Click

Five Nights at Freddy's
Shared: Horror · Indie · Point & Click

Tiny Bunny
Shared: Atmospheric · Horror · Dark

Stories Untold
Shared: Adventure · Indie · Atmospheric

Bad Dream: Coma
Shared: Adventure · Point & Click · Indie

Last Report
Shared: Point & Click · Atmospheric · Horror

Rusty Lake Hotel
Shared: Point & Click · Adventure · Indie