Games like Stay
Games like Stay include Life is Strange: True Colors, Life is Strange Remastered, Life is Strange: Before the Storm Remastered, Life is Strange: Double Exposure, and Tomb Raider Game of the Year. We matched them by the tags players give Stay on Steam (Puzzle, Female Protagonist, Third Person, 3D, and LGBTQ+): closest matches first, and among equally close ones the better-known games.

Life is Strange: True Colors
Shared: Female Protagonist · LGBTQ+ · Choices Matter

Life is Strange Remastered
Shared: Female Protagonist · Choices Matter · LGBTQ+

Life is Strange: Before the Storm Remastered
Shared: Female Protagonist · LGBTQ+ · Choices Matter

Life is Strange: Double Exposure
Shared: Female Protagonist · LGBTQ+ · Choices Matter

Tomb Raider Game of the Year
Shared: Female Protagonist · Third Person · Action

Lost Records: Bloom & Rage
Shared: Female Protagonist · LGBTQ+ · Choices Matter

Rise of the Tomb Raider™
Shared: Female Protagonist · Third Person · Puzzle

Life is Strange: Before the Storm
Shared: Female Protagonist · Choices Matter · Story Rich

Life is Strange: Reunion
Shared: LGBTQ+ · Female Protagonist · Choices Matter

A Plague Tale: Innocence
Shared: Female Protagonist · Third Person · Story Rich

Detroit: Become Human
Shared: Choices Matter · Multiple Endings · Story Rich

Stellar Blade™
Shared: Female Protagonist · Third Person · Action

Dreamfall Chapters
Shared: Female Protagonist · Choices Matter · Third Person

Tomb Raider I-III Remastered Starring Lara Croft
Shared: Female Protagonist · Puzzle · 3D

Tomb Raider: Legend
Shared: Female Protagonist · Puzzle · Third Person

Hellblade: Senua's Sacrifice
Shared: Female Protagonist · Third Person · Story Rich

Sherlock Holmes: The Devil's Daughter
Shared: Puzzle · Third Person · Story Rich

The Killing Antidote
Shared: Female Protagonist · 3D · Third Person

UNCHARTED™: Legacy of Thieves Collection
Shared: Puzzle · Third Person · Story Rich

Tomb Raider: Underworld
Shared: Female Protagonist · Puzzle · Third Person

Brothers - A Tale of Two Sons
Shared: Puzzle · Controller · Story Rich

The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt — Remastered
Shared: Third Person · Story Rich · Choices Matter

Magical Girl Witch Trials
Shared: Female Protagonist · LGBTQ+ · Story Rich

OneShot
Shared: Puzzle · Story Rich · Choices Matter