Games like Social Caterpillar
Games like Social Caterpillar include OneShot, ANIMAL WELL, Outer Wilds, Until Then, and Turnip Boy Commits Tax Evasion. We matched them by the tags players give Social Caterpillar on Steam (Exploration, Interactive Fiction, Puzzle, 2D, and Top-Down): closest matches first, and among equally close ones the better-known games.

OneShot
Shared: Puzzle · Story Rich · Pixel Graphics

ANIMAL WELL
Shared: Exploration · Puzzle · 2D

Outer Wilds
Shared: Exploration · Puzzle · Story Rich

Until Then
Shared: Interactive Fiction · 2D · Story Rich

Turnip Boy Commits Tax Evasion
Shared: Exploration · Puzzle · Top-Down

There Is No Game: Wrong Dimension
Shared: Puzzle · 2D · Pixel Graphics

No Case Should Remain Unsolved
Shared: Interactive Fiction · Puzzle · Story Rich

Impostor Factory
Shared: 2D · Story Rich · Top-Down

Murders on the Yangtze River
Shared: Puzzle · Exploration · Story Rich

FEZ
Shared: Puzzle · Exploration · Pixel Graphics

Ib
Shared: Exploration · 2D · Puzzle

Blue Prince
Shared: Exploration · Puzzle · Story Rich

Papers, Please
Shared: Puzzle · Multiple Endings · Pixel Graphics

Finding Paradise
Shared: 2D · Story Rich · Interactive Fiction

Gorogoa
Shared: Puzzle · Casual · 2D

Hollow Knight
Shared: 2D · Exploration · Indie

OMORI
Shared: Story Rich · Multiple Endings · 2D

UNREAL LIFE
Shared: Exploration · Puzzle · Story Rich

Word Game
Shared: Exploration · Puzzle · 2D

Storyteller
Shared: Puzzle · Interactive Fiction · 2D

A Space for the Unbound
Shared: Exploration · Puzzle · Story Rich

The Case of the Golden Idol
Shared: Puzzle · 2D · Interactive Fiction

To the Moon
Shared: Interactive Fiction · Story Rich · Pixel Graphics

Baba Is You
Shared: Puzzle · 2D · Indie