Games like Secret Santa
Games like Secret Santa include Party Hard, Gunpoint, The Escapists 2, Into the Breach, and Shadow Tactics: Blades of the Shogun. We matched them by the tags players give Secret Santa on Steam (Indie, Strategy, Pixel Graphics, and Stealth): closest matches first, and among equally close ones the better-known games.

Party Hard
Shared: Pixel Graphics · Strategy · Stealth

Gunpoint
Shared: Indie · Stealth · Pixel Graphics

The Escapists 2
Shared: Strategy · Pixel Graphics · Indie

Into the Breach
Shared: Strategy · Indie · Pixel Graphics

Shadow Tactics: Blades of the Shogun
Shared: Strategy · Stealth · Indie

Party Hard 2
Shared: Indie · Pixel Graphics · Strategy

DEADBOLT
Shared: Pixel Graphics · Indie · Stealth

The Escapists
Shared: Strategy · Pixel Graphics · Indie

Balatro
Shared: Strategy · Pixel Graphics · Indie

Dungeon of the ENDLESS™
Shared: Strategy · Indie · Pixel Graphics

Papers, Please
Shared: Indie · Pixel Graphics · Strategy

UFO 50
Shared: Indie · Pixel Graphics · Strategy

Monaco: What's Yours Is Mine
Shared: Indie · Stealth · Strategy

Hero's Adventure: Road to Passion
Shared: Strategy · Indie · Pixel Graphics

Crying Suns
Shared: Strategy · Indie · Pixel Graphics

Heat Signature
Shared: Indie · Stealth · Strategy

Wargroove
Shared: Strategy · Pixel Graphics · Indie

Zombie Night Terror
Shared: Strategy · Indie · Pixel Graphics

Tooth and Tail
Shared: Strategy · Indie · Pixel Graphics

Cookie Clicker
Shared: Indie · Pixel Graphics · Strategy

The Binding of Isaac: Rebirth
Shared: Indie · Pixel Graphics

Loop Hero
Shared: Pixel Graphics · Indie · Strategy

Your Only Move Is HUSTLE
Shared: Strategy · Pixel Graphics · Indie

Yes, Your Grace
Shared: Indie · Pixel Graphics · Strategy