Games like Secret Ponchos
Games like Secret Ponchos include Red Dead Redemption 2, PUBG: BATTLEGROUNDS, Red Dead Online, Grand Theft Auto V Legacy, and Paladins®. We matched them by the tags players give Secret Ponchos on Steam (Western, Action, Indie, Multiplayer, and MOBA): closest matches first, and among equally close ones the better-known games.

Red Dead Redemption 2
Shared: Western · Multiplayer · Action

PUBG: BATTLEGROUNDS
Shared: Multiplayer · Shooter · Action

Red Dead Online
Shared: Western · Action · Multiplayer

Grand Theft Auto V Legacy
Shared: Action · Multiplayer · Shooter

Paladins®
Shared: Multiplayer · Action · Shooter

Apex Legends™
Shared: Multiplayer · Action · Shooter

WARDOGS
Shared: Action · Multiplayer · Shooter

SMITE®
Shared: Action · Multiplayer · MOBA

Stick Fight: The Game
Shared: Multiplayer · Action · Fighting

Far Far West
Shared: Western · Multiplayer · Action

Rust
Shared: Multiplayer · Action · PvP

How to Fish
Shared: Multiplayer · Indie · Shooter

Call of Duty®
Shared: Multiplayer · Action · Shooter

Broforce
Shared: Action · Multiplayer · Indie

ROUNDS
Shared: Multiplayer · Action · Fighting

Absolver
Shared: Action · Multiplayer · Fighting

Left 4 Dead 2
Shared: Multiplayer · Action · Shooter

Grand Theft Auto V Enhanced
Shared: Action · Multiplayer · Shooter

Counter-Strike
Shared: Action · Multiplayer · Shooter

NARAKA: BLADEPOINT
Shared: Multiplayer · Action · PvP

Counter-Strike: Source
Shared: Action · Shooter · Multiplayer

Arma 3
Shared: Action · Multiplayer · Shooter

ShellShock Live
Shared: Multiplayer · Action · Shooter

ORION: Prelude
Shared: Action · Multiplayer · Indie