Games like Reindeer Wrangler
Games like Reindeer Wrangler include Braid, LIMBO, Trine 2: Complete Story, Defy Gravity Extended, and Webbed. We matched them by the tags players give Reindeer Wrangler on Steam (Puzzle Platformer, Casual, 2D, Elves, and Snow): closest matches first, and among equally close ones the better-known games.

Braid
Shared: Puzzle Platformer · 2D · Puzzle

LIMBO
Shared: Puzzle Platformer · 2D · Platformer

Trine 2: Complete Story
Shared: Puzzle Platformer · Platformer · 2D Platformer

Defy Gravity Extended
Shared: Puzzle Platformer · 2D · Platformer

Webbed
Shared: Puzzle Platformer · 2D · 2D Platformer

Laughing to Die
Shared: Casual · Puzzle Platformer · Platformer

KarmaZoo
Shared: Casual · Puzzle Platformer · 2D

FEZ
Shared: Platformer · Casual · Puzzle

Toki Tori
Shared: Casual · Puzzle · 2D

Hue
Shared: Puzzle Platformer · 2D · Puzzle

Zup! F
Shared: Casual · 2D · Puzzle

Pikuniku
Shared: Casual · Puzzle · Indie

Thomas Was Alone
Shared: Puzzle Platformer · Platformer · 2D

Zup!
Shared: Casual · 2D · Puzzle

Planet of Lana
Shared: Puzzle Platformer · Puzzle · 2D Platformer

Nihilumbra
Shared: Casual · Puzzle Platformer · 2D

Zup! 2
Shared: Casual · 2D · Puzzle

Zup! 8
Shared: Casual · 2D · Puzzle

Munin
Shared: Puzzle Platformer · Casual · 2D

Zup! X
Shared: Casual · 2D · Puzzle

Öoo
Shared: Puzzle Platformer · 2D · Puzzle

Mind Over Magnet
Shared: Puzzle Platformer · 2D · Puzzle

Trine Enchanted Edition
Shared: Puzzle Platformer · 2D Platformer · Family Friendly

Zup! 3
Shared: Casual · 2D · Puzzle