Games like Pony Island
Games like Pony Island include OneShot, Sally Face - Episode One, DISTRAINT: Deluxe Edition, Little Nightmares II, and Little Nightmares. We matched them by the tags players give Pony Island on Steam (Puzzle, Indie, Psychological Horror, Pixel Graphics, and Hacking): closest matches first, and among equally close ones the better-known games.
OneShot
Shared: Indie · Pixel Graphics · Puzzle
Sally Face - Episode One
Shared: Indie · Psychological Horror · Puzzle
DISTRAINT: Deluxe Edition
Shared: Indie · Psychological Horror · Pixel Graphics
Little Nightmares II
Shared: Puzzle · Singleplayer · Horror
Little Nightmares
Shared: Puzzle · Horror · Singleplayer
Poppy Playtime
Shared: Puzzle · Singleplayer · Horror
OMORI
Shared: Psychological Horror · Indie · Pixel Graphics
Firework
Shared: Indie · Puzzle · Psychological Horror
Fran Bow
Shared: Psychological Horror · Puzzle · Indie
Undertale
Shared: Pixel Graphics · Indie · Great Soundtrack
Changed
Shared: Puzzle · Psychological Horror · Pixel Graphics
The Hex
Shared: Indie · Psychological Horror · Singleplayer
The Witch's House MV
Shared: Indie · Pixel Graphics · Psychological Horror
Papers, Please
Shared: Indie · Pixel Graphics · Puzzle
Bendy and the Ink Machine
Shared: Puzzle · Singleplayer · Horror
Please, Don’t Touch Anything
Shared: Puzzle · Indie · Pixel Graphics
Detention
Shared: Indie · Psychological Horror · Puzzle
FAITH: The Unholy Trinity
Shared: Psychological Horror · Indie · Pixel Graphics
Replica
Shared: Indie · Puzzle · Pixel Graphics
LIMBO
Shared: Indie · Puzzle · Dark
IMSCARED
Shared: Indie · Psychological Horror · Pixel Graphics
There Is No Game: Wrong Dimension
Shared: Puzzle · Indie · Pixel Graphics
Gunpoint
Shared: Indie · Puzzle · Pixel Graphics
Rusty Lake Paradise
Shared: Puzzle · Indie · Psychological Horror