Games like Pilgrims
Games like Pilgrims include Gorogoa, Hidden Folks, Return to Monkey Island, Thank Goodness You're Here!, and Donut County. We matched them by the tags players give Pilgrims on Steam (Hand-drawn, Short, Stylized, Funny, and Cartoon): closest matches first, and among equally close ones the better-known games.

Gorogoa
Shared: Hand-drawn · Singleplayer · Short

Hidden Folks
Shared: Hand-drawn · Funny · Relaxing

Return to Monkey Island
Shared: Funny · Hand-drawn · Singleplayer

Thank Goodness You're Here!
Shared: Hand-drawn · Funny · Short

Donut County
Shared: Funny · Short · Singleplayer

CHUCHEL
Shared: Funny · Cartoon · Point & Click

Gomo
Shared: Short · Hand-drawn · Singleplayer

Passpartout: The Starving Artist
Shared: Hand-drawn · Singleplayer · Funny

Deponia
Shared: Funny · Singleplayer · Point & Click

The Henry Stickmin Collection
Shared: Funny · Singleplayer · Hand-drawn

Carto
Shared: Hand-drawn · Relaxing · Singleplayer

Creaks
Shared: Hand-drawn · Stylized · Cartoon

Machinarium
Shared: Hand-drawn · Point & Click · 2D

Old Man's Journey
Shared: Hand-drawn · Stylized · Family Friendly

Lost in Play
Shared: Funny · Hand-drawn · 2D

Mizi NO!
Shared: Hand-drawn · Cartoon · 2D

There Is No Game: Wrong Dimension
Shared: Funny · Point & Click · Singleplayer

Little Inferno
Shared: Funny · Singleplayer · Short

Draw & Guess
Shared: Funny · Relaxing · 2D

Assemble with Care
Shared: Short · Relaxing · Singleplayer

Samorost 3
Shared: Hand-drawn · Stylized · Relaxing

TOEM: A Photo Adventure
Shared: Hand-drawn · Relaxing · Funny

Birth
Shared: Hand-drawn · Stylized · Relaxing

Later Alligator
Shared: Funny · Point & Click · Singleplayer

