Games like Pawfish Bay
Games like Pawfish Bay include Stardew Valley, Cat Goes Fishing, DAVE THE DIVER, Touhou Mystia's Izakaya, and Papa's Freezeria Deluxe. We matched them by the tags players give Pawfish Bay on Steam (Time Management, Fishing, Farming Sim, 2D, and Cute): closest matches first, and among equally close ones the better-known games.

Stardew Valley
Shared: Farming Sim · Pixel Graphics · Simulation

Cat Goes Fishing
Shared: Fishing · 2D · Cute

DAVE THE DIVER
Shared: Casual · Pixel Graphics · Fishing

Touhou Mystia's Izakaya
Shared: Time Management · Casual · Pixel Graphics

Papa's Freezeria Deluxe
Shared: Time Management · Casual · Simulation

Unpacking
Shared: Cute · Casual · Pixel Graphics

Fields of Mistria
Shared: Farming Sim · Pixel Graphics · Cute

Tiny Pasture
Shared: Farming Sim · Cute · Casual

PomoFarm
Shared: Time Management · Farming Sim · Casual

WEBFISHING
Shared: Fishing · Cute · Casual

Lemon Cake
Shared: Farming Sim · Cute · Time Management

Maltese's Fluffy Onsen
Shared: Cute · Simulation · Pixel Graphics

Papers, Please
Shared: Simulation · Pixel Graphics · Indie

Screen Cat
Shared: Cute · Casual · Cats

Fishing Planet
Shared: Fishing · Simulation · Free to Play

Farm Together 2
Shared: Farming Sim · Time Management · Cute

Little Witch in the Woods
Shared: Cute · Pixel Graphics · Casual

Sticky Business
Shared: Casual · Cute · Simulation

Vampire Survivors
Shared: 2D · Pixel Graphics · Casual

Game Dev Tycoon
Shared: Simulation · Casual · 2D

OneShot
Shared: Cute · Pixel Graphics · Indie

STORY OF SEASONS: Friends of Mineral Town
Shared: Farming Sim · Casual · Simulation

Montaro
Shared: Cute · Casual · 2D

Sword and Fairy Inn 2
Shared: Casual · Time Management · Farming Sim