Games like Paper Enchantress
Games like Paper Enchantress include LoveChoice, Our Life: Beginnings & Always, Undertale, I Wani Hug that Gator!, and Senren * Banka. We matched them by the tags players give Paper Enchantress on Steam (Visual Novel, Casual, 2D, Choices Matter, and Multiple Endings): closest matches first, and among equally close ones the better-known games.

LoveChoice
Shared: Visual Novel · Choices Matter · Romance

Our Life: Beginnings & Always
Shared: Visual Novel · Romance · Choices Matter

Undertale
Shared: Choices Matter · Multiple Endings · 2D

I Wani Hug that Gator!
Shared: Visual Novel · Choices Matter · Romance

Senren * Banka
Shared: Visual Novel · Casual · Romance

CLANNAD
Shared: Visual Novel · Romance · Multiple Endings

Emily is Away <3
Shared: Choices Matter · Casual · Multiple Endings

The Cosmic Wheel Sisterhood
Shared: Visual Novel · Choices Matter · Magic

BAD END THEATER
Shared: Visual Novel · Multiple Endings · Choices Matter

Dispatch
Shared: Choices Matter · Romance · Casual

Tyrion Cuthbert: Attorney of the Arcane
Shared: Visual Novel · Fantasy · Casual

Fate/stay night REMASTERED
Shared: Visual Novel · Multiple Endings · Choices Matter

ATRI -My Dear Moments-
Shared: Visual Novel · Casual · Romance

Kingdom Rush Frontiers - Tower Defense
Shared: 2D · Choices Matter · Casual

An alt girl for skoof
Shared: Visual Novel · Casual · Multiple Endings

The Henry Stickmin Collection
Shared: Multiple Endings · Choices Matter · 2D

Martial Law
Shared: Choices Matter · Multiple Endings · Free to Play

Volcano Princess
Shared: Choices Matter · Multiple Endings · Visual Novel

Until Then
Shared: Visual Novel · 2D · Romance

Love Is All Around
Shared: Visual Novel · Romance · Multiple Endings

Summer Pockets REFLECTION BLUE
Shared: Visual Novel · Multiple Endings · 2D

Doki Doki Literature Club Plus!
Shared: Visual Novel · Romance · Multiple Endings

Lucy -The Eternity She Wished For-
Shared: Visual Novel · Romance · Multiple Endings

Flowers Blooming at the End of Summer
Shared: Visual Novel · Casual · Romance