Games like New Ice York
Games like New Ice York include Outer Wilds, Firewatch, Unheard - Voices of Crime, What Remains of Edith Finch, and L.A. Noire. We matched them by the tags players give New Ice York on Steam (Mystery, Dark Comedy, Crime, Surreal, and Story Rich): closest matches first, and among equally close ones the better-known games.

Outer Wilds
Shared: Mystery · Story Rich · Exploration

Firewatch
Shared: Mystery · Story Rich · Atmospheric

Unheard - Voices of Crime
Shared: Mystery · Crime · Story Rich

What Remains of Edith Finch
Shared: Mystery · Story Rich · Atmospheric

L.A. Noire
Shared: Crime · Mystery · Story Rich

Staffer Case: A Supernatural Mystery Adventure
Shared: Mystery · Story Rich · Crime

Sherlock Holmes: The Devil's Daughter
Shared: Mystery · Story Rich · Crime

Disco Elysium - The Final Cut
Shared: Story Rich · Surreal · Atmospheric

Hylics
Shared: Surreal · Psychedelic · Atmospheric

Return of the Obra Dinn
Shared: Mystery · Story Rich · Detective

Contradiction: Spot The Liar
Shared: Crime · Mystery · Detective

Murders on the Yangtze River
Shared: Mystery · Story Rich · Exploration

Sherlock Holmes: Crimes and Punishments
Shared: Mystery · Crime · Story Rich

Murdered: Soul Suspect
Shared: Mystery · Crime · Detective

Danganronpa 2: Goodbye Despair
Shared: Mystery · Story Rich · Dark Comedy

Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney Trilogy
Shared: Mystery · Story Rich · Crime

CARIMARA: Beneath the forlorn limbs
Shared: Mystery · Story Rich · Exploration

Paradise Killer
Shared: Story Rich · Surreal · Exploration

INDIKA
Shared: Surreal · Story Rich · Psychedelic

Sherlock Holmes Chapter One
Shared: Mystery · Story Rich · Crime

The Forgotten City
Shared: Mystery · Story Rich · Exploration

Danganronpa: Trigger Happy Havoc
Shared: Mystery · Story Rich · Dark Comedy

The Operator
Shared: Mystery · Crime · Conspiracy

The Rise of the Golden Idol
Shared: Mystery · Crime · Conspiracy