Games like My Garage
Games like My Garage include BeamNG.drive, Forza Horizon 5, My Summer Car, Forza Horizon 6, and Assetto Corsa. We matched them by the tags players give My Garage on Steam (Automobile Sim, Simulation, Open World, Realistic, and Racing): closest matches first, and among equally close ones the better-known games.

BeamNG.drive
Shared: Simulation · Automobile Sim · Realistic

Forza Horizon 5
Shared: Open World · Automobile Sim · Racing

My Summer Car
Shared: Automobile Sim · Simulation · Open World

Forza Horizon 6
Shared: Open World · Automobile Sim · Racing

Assetto Corsa
Shared: Automobile Sim · Simulation · Racing

Car Mechanic Simulator 2018
Shared: Automobile Sim · Simulation · Realistic

SnowRunner
Shared: Automobile Sim · Simulation · Realistic

City Car Driving
Shared: Simulation · Automobile Sim · Open World

Car Mechanic Simulator 2021
Shared: Automobile Sim · Simulation · Realistic

American Truck Simulator
Shared: Automobile Sim · Open World · Simulation

Euro Truck Simulator 2
Shared: Simulation · Automobile Sim · Open World

MudRunner
Shared: Simulation · Automobile Sim · Realistic

Grand Theft Auto V Legacy
Shared: Open World · Automobile Sim · Multiplayer

Assetto Corsa Competizione
Shared: Automobile Sim · Simulation · Racing

The Long Drive
Shared: Open World · Automobile Sim · Multiplayer

CarX Drift Racing Online
Shared: Simulation · Racing · Multiplayer

Mon Bazou
Shared: Automobile Sim · Sandbox · Racing

The Crew™ 2
Shared: Automobile Sim · Open World · Racing

CarX Street
Shared: Open World · Automobile Sim · Racing

DiRT Rally 2.0
Shared: Automobile Sim · Simulation · Racing

Wreckfest
Shared: Automobile Sim · Simulation · Racing

Euro Truck Simulator
Shared: Automobile Sim · Simulation · Open World

Forza Motorsport
Shared: Automobile Sim · Racing · Simulation

Drive Beyond Horizons
Shared: Automobile Sim · Open World · Simulation