Games like Mafia is Alive
Games like Mafia is Alive include Town of Salem, Last Oasis, Notes of Soul, Costume Quest, and Witch It. We matched them by the tags players give Mafia is Alive on Steam (RPG, Massively Multiplayer, Indie, Casual, and Early Access): closest matches first, and among equally close ones the better-known games.

Town of Salem
Shared: RPG · Indie · Casual

Last Oasis
Shared: Massively Multiplayer · RPG · Survival

Notes of Soul
Shared: Massively Multiplayer · RPG · Indie

Costume Quest
Shared: RPG · Casual · Comedy

Witch It
Shared: Indie · Casual · Funny

Outlaws of the Old West
Shared: Massively Multiplayer · Survival · Indie

Project: Gorgon
Shared: RPG · Massively Multiplayer · Indie

Tower Unite
Shared: Casual · Massively Multiplayer · Indie

DELTARUNE
Shared: RPG · Funny · Comedy

Golf With Your Friends
Shared: Casual · Indie · Funny

Comedy Night
Shared: Casual · Comedy · RPG

Dark and Light
Shared: Massively Multiplayer · RPG · Survival

Donut County
Shared: Indie · Casual · Funny

Undertale
Shared: RPG · Indie · Funny

Plants vs. Zombies GOTY Edition
Shared: Casual · Comedy · Family Friendly

Home Behind
Shared: RPG · Indie · Casual

West of Loathing
Shared: RPG · Comedy · Indie

There Is No Game: Wrong Dimension
Shared: Indie · Casual · Comedy

MECCHA CHAMELEON
Shared: Casual · Funny · Comedy

Who's Your Daddy?!
Shared: Funny · Comedy · Casual

Hand Simulator: Survival
Shared: Survival · RPG · Indie

Beasts of Bermuda
Shared: Massively Multiplayer · Survival · Indie

Obenseuer
Shared: Indie · RPG · Survival

Goat Simulator
Shared: Comedy · Funny · Casual