Games like Eye Of Plunder
Games like Eye Of Plunder include Vampire Survivors, Timberman, UFO 50, Trip to Vinelands, and There Is No Game: Wrong Dimension. We matched them by the tags players give Eye Of Plunder on Steam (Casual, Indie, Action, Pixel Graphics, and Procedural Generation): closest matches first, and among equally close ones the better-known games.

Vampire Survivors
Shared: Pixel Graphics · Indie · Casual

Timberman
Shared: Casual · Indie · Pixel Graphics

UFO 50
Shared: Indie · Pixel Graphics · Action

Trip to Vinelands
Shared: Indie · Action · Pixel Graphics

There Is No Game: Wrong Dimension
Shared: Indie · Puzzle · Pixel Graphics

Baba Is You
Shared: Indie · Puzzle · Pixel Graphics

Unpacking
Shared: Casual · Pixel Graphics · Puzzle

Gensokyo Night Festival
Shared: Indie · Action · Casual

Cyberhunt
Shared: Indie · Casual · Action

Zup! S
Shared: Casual · Indie · Puzzle

Skul: The Hero Slayer
Shared: Indie · Action · Pixel Graphics

Broforce
Shared: Action · Pixel Graphics · Indie

Pikuniku
Shared: Indie · Casual · Puzzle

The Binding of Isaac: Rebirth
Shared: Indie · Pixel Graphics · Dungeon Crawler

Cookie Clicker
Shared: Casual · Indie · Pixel Graphics

OneShot
Shared: Indie · Pixel Graphics · Puzzle

Superflight
Shared: Indie · Casual · Procedural Generation

Papers, Please
Shared: Indie · Pixel Graphics · Puzzle

Rhythm Doctor
Shared: Pixel Graphics · Indie · Action

Zup!
Shared: Casual · Indie · Puzzle

To The Core
Shared: Casual · Indie · Procedural Generation

Downwell
Shared: Indie · Pixel Graphics · Action

10,000,000
Shared: Indie · Casual · Pixel Graphics

Zup! 4
Shared: Casual · Indie · Puzzle