Games like Cinders
Games like Cinders include LoveChoice, Love Is All Around, Volcano Princess, The Wolf Among Us, and Life is Strange: True Colors. We matched them by the tags players give Cinders on Steam (Visual Novel, Choices Matter, Female Protagonist, Choose Your Own Adventure, and Story Rich): closest matches first, and among equally close ones the better-known games.

LoveChoice
Shared: Choices Matter · Visual Novel · Story Rich

Love Is All Around
Shared: Visual Novel · Dating Sim · Choices Matter

Volcano Princess
Shared: Choices Matter · Female Protagonist · Multiple Endings

The Wolf Among Us
Shared: Choices Matter · Story Rich · Visual Novel

Life is Strange: True Colors
Shared: Choices Matter · Female Protagonist · Story Rich

私のリアルは充実しすぎている フルボイス版
Shared: Visual Novel · Female Protagonist · Otome

The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt — Remastered
Shared: Story Rich · Choices Matter · Atmospheric

Life is Strange: Before the Storm
Shared: Choices Matter · Story Rich · Female Protagonist

Slay the Princess — The Pristine Cut
Shared: Visual Novel · Choices Matter · Story Rich

Ten Trials of Babel: The Doppelganger Maze
Shared: Female Protagonist · Multiple Endings · Story Rich

Far Away
Shared: Visual Novel · Choices Matter · Female Protagonist

Amnesia™: Memories
Shared: Visual Novel · Female Protagonist · Otome

Homicipher
Shared: Visual Novel · Female Protagonist · Otome

I Wani Hug that Gator!
Shared: Visual Novel · Choices Matter · Story Rich

Detroit: Become Human
Shared: Choices Matter · Story Rich · Multiple Endings

CLANNAD
Shared: Visual Novel · Story Rich · Multiple Endings

Folie Fatale
Shared: Visual Novel · Female Protagonist · Choose Your Own Adventure

Undertale
Shared: Choices Matter · Story Rich · Multiple Endings

Road to Empress I
Shared: Choices Matter · Female Protagonist · Visual Novel

Hatoful Boyfriend
Shared: Visual Novel · Female Protagonist · Story Rich

The Test
Shared: Choose Your Own Adventure · Story Rich · Multiple Endings

BAD END THEATER
Shared: Visual Novel · Choices Matter · Multiple Endings

STEINS;GATE
Shared: Visual Novel · Story Rich · Choices Matter

Our Life: Beginnings & Always
Shared: Visual Novel · Choices Matter · Romance