Games like Castle Story
Games like Castle Story include Terraria, Rust, Raft, Project Zomboid, and ARK: Survival Evolved. We matched them by the tags players give Castle Story on Steam (Colony Sim, Strategy, Building, Sandbox, and Multiplayer): closest matches first, and among equally close ones the better-known games.

Terraria
Shared: Sandbox · Open World Survival Craft · Multiplayer

Rust
Shared: Survival · Multiplayer · Building

Raft
Shared: Multiplayer · Survival · Building

Project Zomboid
Shared: Survival · Multiplayer · Sandbox

ARK: Survival Evolved
Shared: Multiplayer · Survival · Open World Survival Craft

Don't Starve Together
Shared: Survival · Multiplayer · Open World Survival Craft

Valheim
Shared: Survival · Open World Survival Craft · Building

Conan Exiles Enhanced
Shared: Building · Survival · Multiplayer

Palworld
Shared: Survival · Multiplayer · Open World Survival Craft

Craft The World
Shared: Colony Sim · Sandbox · Building

Stonehearth
Shared: Colony Sim · Building · Sandbox

7 Days to Die
Shared: Survival · Multiplayer · Open World Survival Craft

Once Human
Shared: Multiplayer · Survival · Building

Scrap Mechanic
Shared: Building · Sandbox · Multiplayer

Oxygen Not Included
Shared: Colony Sim · Building · Survival

TerraTech
Shared: Building · Sandbox · Multiplayer

ASKA
Shared: Colony Sim · Survival · Multiplayer

RimWorld
Shared: Colony Sim · Strategy · Sandbox

The Forest
Shared: Survival · Open World Survival Craft · Building

Satisfactory
Shared: Multiplayer · Building · Sandbox

Colony Survival
Shared: Colony Sim · Building · Survival

Don't Starve
Shared: Survival · Open World Survival Craft · Sandbox

Sons Of The Forest
Shared: Survival · Multiplayer · Building

Space Engineers
Shared: Building · Sandbox · Survival