Games like Caster's Trap
Games like Caster's Trap include Firework, No, I'm not a Human, Poppy Playtime, Sally Face - Episode One, and The Room Two. We matched them by the tags players give Caster's Trap on Steam (Horror, Mystery, Puzzle, Atmospheric, and Magic): closest matches first, and among equally close ones the better-known games.
Firework
Shared: Horror · Puzzle · Mystery
No, I'm not a Human
Shared: Horror · Choices Matter · Atmospheric
Poppy Playtime
Shared: Horror · Puzzle · Mystery
Sally Face - Episode One
Shared: Horror · Puzzle · Mystery
The Room Two
Shared: Mystery · Puzzle · Horror
OneShot
Shared: Atmospheric · Puzzle · Choices Matter
Outer Wilds
Shared: Mystery · Atmospheric · Puzzle
OMORI
Shared: Horror · Psychological Horror · Multiple Endings
Darkwood
Shared: Horror · Atmospheric · Psychological Horror
Cube Escape Collection
Shared: Puzzle · Mystery · Horror
The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt — Remastered
Shared: Atmospheric · Choices Matter · Fantasy
SOMA
Shared: Horror · Atmospheric · Psychological Horror
Bendy and the Ink Machine
Shared: Horror · Puzzle · Mystery
The Room Three
Shared: Mystery · Puzzle · Atmospheric
The Room
Shared: Mystery · Puzzle · Atmospheric
Little Nightmares II
Shared: Horror · Puzzle · Atmospheric
Little Nightmares
Shared: Horror · Atmospheric · Puzzle
Rusty Lake Paradise
Shared: Puzzle · Horror · Atmospheric
ANIMAL WELL
Shared: Puzzle · Horror · Atmospheric
DISTRAINT: Deluxe Edition
Shared: Horror · Psychological Horror · Atmospheric
Endacopia
Shared: Horror · Puzzle · Psychological Horror
Inside the Backrooms
Shared: Horror · Puzzle · Psychological Horror
Fran Bow
Shared: Horror · Puzzle · Psychological Horror
Tormentum - Dark Sorrow
Shared: Horror · Puzzle · Mystery