Games like All My Gods
Games like All My Gods include Banished, Cities: Skylines, Manor Lords, The Promised Land, and Kingdoms and Castles. We matched them by the tags players give All My Gods on Steam (Casual, Colony Sim, Strategy, Adventure, and Simulation): closest matches first, and among equally close ones the better-known games.

Banished
Shared: Colony Sim · Strategy · City Builder

Cities: Skylines
Shared: Simulation · City Builder · Strategy

Manor Lords
Shared: Strategy · Simulation · City Builder

The Promised Land
Shared: Casual · Colony Sim · Strategy

Kingdoms and Castles
Shared: Colony Sim · City Builder · Strategy

SPORE™
Shared: Colony Sim · Casual · Simulation

Prison Architect
Shared: Simulation · Colony Sim · Strategy

Against the Storm
Shared: Strategy · Simulation · City Builder

Frostpunk
Shared: Strategy · City Builder · Colony Sim

Dawn of Man
Shared: Colony Sim · Strategy · City Builder

Empires of the Undergrowth
Shared: Strategy · Simulation · Colony Sim

Dwarf Fortress
Shared: Colony Sim · Strategy · Simulation

RimWorld
Shared: Colony Sim · Strategy · Simulation

Workers & Resources: Soviet Republic
Shared: Strategy · Simulation · City Builder

Mini Motorways
Shared: Casual · Strategy · Simulation

Two Point Museum
Shared: Casual · Simulation · Strategy

Norland
Shared: Strategy · Colony Sim · Simulation

Stonehearth
Shared: Colony Sim · City Builder · Strategy

Ostriv
Shared: Strategy · Colony Sim · City Builder

Planet Zoo 2
Shared: Casual · Strategy · Simulation

Cities: Skylines II
Shared: Simulation · City Builder · Strategy

Townsmen - A Kingdom Rebuilt
Shared: Casual · Strategy · Colony Sim

TheoTown
Shared: Simulation · City Builder · Strategy

Blacksmith Master
Shared: Strategy · Colony Sim · Simulation